A man surnamed Huang led his dog for a walk and failed to tie up his dog, which caused the knight to crash his car. Afterwards, he was very dumbfounded when he saw the list of claims.

(Flipping Google Maps)

[Reporter Huang Jialin/Kaohsiung Report] A man surnamed Huang took 4 dogs out for a walk, and 2 of them were not tied up properly, which caused a motorcycle rider surnamed Luo to crash his car. The dental implant cost of 220,000 yuan was also included, and Huang Nan was dumbfounded: "It is obvious that he only suffered minor injuries, so is he cutting his son?" The judge reviewed the list of losses and only awarded Huang Nan 21,000 yuan in compensation.

The judgment pointed out that at around 8:00 p.m. on February 17 last year, a man surnamed Huang went out for a walk with four pet dogs. Two of the dogs ran around on the road without being tied up. Ou Yixin 1st Road and Guanghua 3rd Road collided with a motorcycle rider surnamed Luo, and Luo Nan fell to the ground and was injured and sent to the hospital.

Please read on...

After the car accident, Luo Nan listed various losses, including medical expenses of more than 24,000 yuan, salary loss of more than 45,000 yuan, motorcycle repair costs of more than 53,000 yuan, IPhoe mobile phones of 21,000 yuan, IPhoe The watch was more than 6,000 yuan, the cost of dental implant damage was 220,000 yuan, and the spiritual comfort money was 75,000 yuan. The total compensation was 450,000 yuan.

Huang Nan was dumbfounded after seeing the details of the claim, thinking that the car accident only caused Luo Nan's limbs to be bruised, and he was willing to pay for the medical expenses, but he didn't want to be treated as a winner.

During the trial in the Kaohsiung Summary Court, the judge compared the documents one by one and found that Luo Nan had a dental implant in 2015, but the car accident did not damage his teeth, so the cost of the dental implant was not allowed to claim. Luo Nan's diagnosis certificate only recorded "rest 3 days", so based on Luo Nan's salary calculation, Huang Nan only needs to pay more than 4,000 yuan in salary at most.

In addition, Luo Nan's motorcycle is more than 10 years old. The accident caused only slight damage to the exterior. The judge believed that the damage was only worth 5,000 yuan. As for the IPhoe and watch, the judge examined the photos of the accident scene and found that there was no damage. Relevant evidence proved that the mobile phone and watch were damaged, and Luo Nan did not provide supporting evidence. Therefore, based on the medical expenses of more than 1,000 yuan, the spiritual comfort fund of 10,000 yuan and various recoverable losses, Huang Nan should only be sentenced to 20,000 yuan in compensation. $1,000, subject to appeal.