The man surnamed Huang went to the shrimp fishing farm to sing happily, and went to the wrong box and was beaten in the left eye.

(Photo taken from the Facebook fan of the shrimp fishing farm)

[Reporter Huang Jialin / Kaohsiung Report] The man surnamed Liu and his friends went to the shrimp fishing farm to sing and drink. They went out to the toilet during the dinner. When they returned to the box, a strange man was suddenly behind him. During the conflict, Liu Nan casually smashed the man with a wine bottle, causing serious injury to his left eye. After treatment, he was determined to be blind. The Kaohsiung District Court sentenced Liu Nan to 5 years and 6 months in prison for serious injury.

The judgment pointed out that at 5:00 a.m. on April 21, 2020, a man surnamed Liu and a group of friends sang and drank in the box of a shrimp fishing farm in Linyuan District. Liu Nan walked out of the box to go to the toilet when he was halfway through singing, and when he returned to the box, he found Followed by a man surnamed Huang who did not know, Huang Nan went to the wrong box and had a quarrel with Liu Nan, which eventually evolved into Quan Wuxing.

Please read on...

During the conflict, the two sides smashed each other's heads with wine bottles. Huang Nan's friend in the next box heard the quarrel and rushed to check. Both sides held Liu and Huang respectively. However, Huang Nan was seriously injured when he was sent to the hospital. Concussion, traumatic optic neuropathy of the left eye, eyeball atrophy and other injuries occurred, and the left eye was confirmed to be blind after treatment.

During the trial at the Kaohsiung District Court, Liu Nan argued that during the conflict, his glasses were knocked off, and it was dark in the box. , and he was attacked first, it should be a legitimate defense, even if the defense is excessive, it should only establish the crime of causing serious injury.

However, the judge summoned a number of witnesses from both sides to appear in court. According to multiple testimonies, it was found that Liu Nan had beaten Huang Nan several times with a glass bottle, and when Liu Nan touched the glass bottle with his hand, he felt and heard the beating from the bottle. It was impossible not to know that he was smashing someone with a wine bottle because of the sound of the shot, so he did not accept Liu Nan's words, and Yiyi was sentenced to 5 years and 6 months in prison for the crime of serious injury, which can be appealed.